California Scholars for Academic Freedom

Letter to Dr. Leslie Wong, President SFSU, re. Amcha letter


Letter from California Scholars for Academic Freedom


Dr. Leslie Wong, President

San Francisco State University


CSU Board of Trustees


Dear President Wong and CSU Board of Trustees;


We write on behalf of California Scholars for Academic Freedom (cs4af)* to express concerns about accusations made in a letter addressed to you by the Amcha Initiative. The March 5 letter is co-signed by Scholars for Peace in the Middle East; Simon Wiesenthal Center, Campus Outreach; Stand With Us; and Zionist Organization of America West. It is posted on the Amcha website along with highly inflammatory accusations against San Francisco State University faculty members and students. One link on the Amcha site is titled, “SFSU Prof Advocates Violence against Israel” and SFSU Professor Rabab Abdulhadi is denounced as “the faculty advisor to the former knife-wielding student” [1].


The Amcha letter describes as “deeply troubling” the SFSU academic event, “Report and Discussion From Members of the North American Based Academic and Labor Delegation to Palestine 2014.”  We understand that the SFSU faculty members participating in the Arab and Muslim Ethnicities and Diasporas Initiative previously met with Palestinians from a wide range of backgrounds and perspectives, including members of the Palestinian Legislative Council both in the West Bank and the 1948 areas, members of the Israeli Communist Party, PLO (Fatah, PFLP, DFLP, Fida, PPP, and Arab Liberation Front) and outside the PLO (Hamas) as well political independents, and with professors from the Hebrew University and Ben Gurion University.  The point of the meeting at San Francisco State University, to which the Amcha Initiative objected, was to describe and discuss those prior meetings.


The Amcha Initiative letter accuses SFSU faculty members of meeting with Palestinians, whom Amcha labels hyperbolically as terrorists or of having terrorist associations.  In a blatant attempt at censorship, Amcha calls upon President Wong to speak forcefully against the event, “to monitor it carefully for antisemitic and anti-Israel animus” and “(if it is permitted to go forward) to provide counter-programming on the antisemitic nature of such BDS activities.”


We urge President Wong not to yield to any of those demands, each of which would be an assault on academic freedom and a barrier to the free exchange of ideas.  For a university president to speak against the aforementioned Report and Discussion or monitor it for anti-Semitic and “anti-Israel animus” would be seen as a form of intimidation of faculty members and students.   Amcha’s proposal for counter-programming is a call for the administration to deligitimize this academic meeting and it is a step toward anti-intellecutalism.  If this principle were applied broadly, then any presentation on global warming, for example, would have to be accompanied by an anti-scientific presentation by climate deniers.


The Amcha Initiative’s McCarthyite tactics are not unique to San Francisco State University.  Amcha has denounced faculty members at other UC and CSU campuses for criticisms of Israel [2] and filed frivolous claims of anti-Semitism against UC campuses, later dismissed by the U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Department of Education [3].  Tammi Rossman-Benjamin, a co-founder of Amcha, has also made a public accusation that Muslim and Palestinian students are generically tied to terrorist organizations [4] and has been linked to spying on student groups [5].  The Amcha Imitative waged a campaign in 2012 to prevent Ilan Pappé from speaking on three CSU campuses.  Ilan Pappé is Professor of History and Director of the European Centre for Palestine Studies, and Co-Director for the Exeter Centre for Ethno-Political Studies at Exeter University.  That effort at censorship failed due in part to the principled defense of academic freedom by three CSU campus presidents [6].


The conflation of criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism has become a standard tactic by the Amcha Initiative and those who seek to censor criticism of Israel.  That tactic itself is fundamentally anti-Semitic because it associates with Jewishness an unending list of well-documented racist policies and crimes against humanity committed by the state of Israel, and it ignores the many Jews who actively oppose those crimes.  Far from the worthy goal of fighting real anti-Semitism, the Amcha Initiative serves the propaganda aims of the government of Israel, at the expense of academic freedom and constitutionally protected rights of California residents.


Public universities have a special responsibility to protect academic freedom and freedom of speech. Academic freedom allows professors to conduct and disseminate scholarly research, to design courses and teach students in the areas of their expertise, and to enjoy First Amendment protections for extramural speech.   These are essential activities for any institution calling itself a university.


We urge you to uphold the academic freedom of faculty members at San Francisco State University and to recognize that the Amcha Initiative is an extremist organization whose goals are inconsistent with academic freedom.




[1] Amcha Iniative Website


[2] Amcha Initiative, The Electronic Intifada,


[3] Victory for campus free speech as US Dept. of Education throws out “anti-Semitism” complaints, by Nora Barrows-Friedman, The Electronic Intifada, 08/28/2013


[4] US university lecturer’s shocking hate speech against Arab, Muslim students condemned, by Nora Barrows-Friedman, The Electronic Intifada 02/12/2013


[5] Documents reveal Zionist group spied on US student delegation to Palestine, by Asa Winstanley and Nora Barrows-Friedman, The Electronic Intifada 29 January 2014


[6] Open letter from Three CSU presidents, Jeffrey Armstron, John Welty, Harry Hellenbrand, February 16, 2012


Contacts (listed alphabetically):


Kevin B. Anderson

Professor of Sociology, Political Science, and Feminist Studies

University of California, Santa Barbara


Mohammad Azadpur

Professor of Philosophy

San Francisco State University


Carole H. Browner

Distinguished Research Professor

Department of Anthropology, Department of Gender Studies,

Center for Culture and Health, Semel Institute for Neuroscience and Human Behavior

University of California, Los Angeles


Richard Falk

Research Fellow

Orfalea Center of International and Global Studies

University of California, Santa Barbara


Manzar Foroohar

History Professor

Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo


Jess Ghannam

Clinical Professor

Department of Psychiatry, and Global Health Sciences

School of Medicine

University of California, San Francisco


Dr. Nubar Hovsepian

Associate Professor of Political Science

Chapman University


Ivan Huber, Ph.D.

Professor Emeritus of Biology

Fairleigh Dickinson University


Professor Mahmood Ibrahim

History Graduate Coordinator and Adviser

California State University Pomona


David Klein

Professor of Mathematics

California State University Northridge


Dennis Kortheuer

Department of History

California State University, Long Beach


Robyn Magalit Rodriguez, Ph.D.

Associate Professor, Asian American Studies

University of California, Davis


Targol Mesbah

Assistant Professor, Anthropology & Social Change

California Institute of Integral Studies


Flagg Miller

Associate Professor

Religious Studies Department

University of California, Davis


Minoo Moallem

Professor, Gender and Women’s Studies Department

University of California at Berkeley


Ahlam Muhtaseb, Ph.D.

Associate Professor of Communication Studies

California State University, San Bernardino


Gabriel Piterberg

Professor of History

Director of the Gustav von Grunebaum Center for Near East Studies

University of California, Los Angeles


James Quesada, Ph.D.

Associate Professor

Department of Anthropology

San Francisco State University


Craig Reinarman

Professor of Sociology and Legal Studies

University of California, Santa Cruz


Rush Rehm

Professor, Theater and Performance Studies, and Classics

Artistic Director, Stanford Summer Theater (SST)

Stanford University


Lisa Rofel

Professor of Anthropology

University of California, Santa Cruz


Vida Samiian, Dean

College of Arts and Humanities

California State University Fresno


Judith Stevenson, Ph.d.

Director, Peace and Social Justice Program

Assistant Professor, Department of Human Development

California State University, Long Beach



**CALIFORNIA SCHOLARS FOR ACADEMIC FREEDOM is a group of nearly 200 academics who teach in 20 California institutions.  The group formed as a response to various violations of academic freedom that were arising from both the post-9/11/2001 climate of civil rights violations and the increasing  attacks on progressive educators by neo-conservatives. Many attacks have been aimed at scholars of Arab, Muslim or Middle Eastern descent or at scholars researching and teaching about the Middle East, Arab and Muslim communities.  Our goal of protecting California Scholars based mainly in institutions of higher education has grown broader in scope to include threats to academic freedom across the United States, and where relevant, globally as well. We recognize that violations of academic freedom anywhere are threats to academic freedom everywhere.



March 13, 2014 - Posted by | Uncategorized | , ,

1 Comment »

  1. […] politically active Palestinians. As expressed by California Scholars for Academic Freedom in their letter to the President of SFSU and California State University Board of Trustees, the call for the state […]

    Pingback by A New War on Speech – Jacobin Dev | September 14, 2016 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: